U:L By You

10 Of The Best True Crime Podcasts As Chosen By You

By Morgan Reardon
11th Mar 2022

a silhouette of a man amongst trees in a forest.

It’s official, we’re straight up obsessed with true crime. And for the real super sleuths among us, there never is enough true crime podcasts out there. Which is why we're always on the hunt for the most shocking, keep-you-up-at-night series to plug into while you're on your morning walk, at the gym, cooking dinner, or going to sleep (you do you).

Need some newbies to download? To celebrate our 10th birthday we asked you, our awesome readers, for your favourite true crime series and you didn't disappoint. Queue up your Spotify peeps, these are the best true crime podcasts worth listening to today.

Up And Vanished

When it comes to true crime podcasts you’re often left hanging at the end of the series, with no resolution. That’s not the case with Up And Vanished and its host Payne Lindsey who’s first season helped to solve the 12-year-old cold case of Tara Grinstead. Which is exactly why UL reader Jenna wanted it added to our best true crime podcasts list. She says,“Payne Lindsey has the best voice and does so much work”—we couldn’t agree more. There’s two more epic seasons to binge. Season two looks into the case of missing single mum Kristal Anne Reisinger, who disappeared in 2016 when she was just 29. And most recently, season three tracks the disappearance of Ashley Loring HeavyRunner, a 20-year-old indigenous woman who went missing from the Blackfeet Nation Indian Reservation in 2017. 


We’re going to go ahead and call this the OG of true crime podcasts. Hosted by journalist Sarah Koenig, Serial follows the 1999 murder of American high-school student Hae Min Lee. Her 17-year-old ex-boyfriend, Adnan Syed, was arrested for the crime, and within a year, he was sentenced to life in prison. The case against him was largely based on the story of one witness, Adnan’s friend Jay, who testified that he helped Adnan bury Hae's body. But Adnan has always maintained he had nothing to do with Hae’s death. Koenig sorts through thousands of documents and interviews with Adnan to try to get to the bottom of the case. There’s also new eps following Adnan’s appeal. UL reader Hank nominated Serial he loved listening to this podcast “when the story is unfolding in real time”. 


What started in 2016 as a one-person side project has grown into an award-winning podcast that includes teams based across multiple continents. In each episode Casefile deep dives into the circumstances, investigations and trials of both solved and unsolved cases from all over the world. From prolific murder trials to relevativly unknown cases, the annoymous narrator leaves no stone unturned in his storytelling. With most eps lasting between one to two hours, this one gets our vote as the best podcast for road trips. Urban List reader Kate says the narrator, “doesn’t input his opinion in the story, he just states the facts”. And like many of you have revealed, a good voice is a key ingredient for an excellent podcast and Casefile certainly delivers.

Darknet Diaries

If you’ve ever wondered what goes on in the dark web, this true crime podcast is for you. Darknet Diaries tackles everything from hackers, breaches and shadow government activity to hacktivism, cybercrime, and all the things that dwell on the hidden parts of the network. Created by Jack Rhysider, a veteran of the security world, he gained his professional knowledge of security by working in a Security Operations Center for a Fortune 500 company—a place where threats are detected and stopped. During that time he was exposed to hundreds of client’s networks ranging from schools to governments and banks giving him a unique perspective on darknet crimes. Urban List reader Lila adds, “He tells you how people pull off these huge crimes” and explains the tech side “in a simple way”.

Dark Poutine

Urban List reader Ollie explains Dark Poutine is, “a Canadian true crime podcast with great format and details, and a sprinkling of humour in it”. Each episode will chronicle a shocking crime that has taken place in Canada and trust us when we say some of them will straight up terrify you. There’s the death of Tim McLean, a 22-year-old baker who was on a bus when a fellow passenger stabbed, beheaded and cannibalised him while horrified passengers looked on—just one year later, the killer was found not guilty. Or there’s the case of teenager Hilary Bonnell who has been missing since 2009, and despite an extensive search has never been found… that is until recently when her cousin was arrested for sex crimes and revealed he might hold the clue to finding her. This podcast will have you hooked from the get go. 

The Night Driver

From The Australian and award-winning journalist Hedley Thomas, The Night Driver will chill you to your core. The podcast follows the story of Janine Vaughan who was abducted one rain-soaked night in Bathurst nearly 20 years ago and was never seen again. To this day, her disappearence and suspected murder has not been solved and her family are desperate for answers. Thomas (who also created the now infamous The Teacher's Pet) will once again turn detective as he explores the flawed police investigation riddled with corruption, the potential suspects (including a former cop) and how Vaughan’s murder tore a regional town apart. Urban List reader Sophia says this podcast kept her on the edge of her seat. 

The Nurse

This new, Aussie true crime podcast will shock you to your core. It follows the ongoing investigations into a paediatric nurse in a quiet Tasmanian town, who has spent over 20 years working with children. Loved by his friends and family, trusted by the community and seen as a father figure to many, what nobody realised was that this nurse was actually hiding a dark and disturbing secret. That is until journalist Camille Bianchi received a phone call that sparked this very podcast. Determined to discover the truth from this very tangled chain of events, Bianchi provides a platform for assault survivors who are bravely sharing their story for the first time. Urban Lister Ben says investigative work behind this podcast made it a must-listen for him.

Chasing Charlie

This seven-part podcast is narrated by all round bad boss private investigator Julia Robson who was approached with a seemingly routine case of a jilted lover. But the more Robson dug into the life of a mysterious lothario called Charlie, the more she realised there was a seriously dark side to this man and that he was leaving a trail of broken hearts and shattered lives in his wake. From New Zealand and Australia to the UK and France, you'l follow Robson on her relentless, seven-year mission for ​the redemption and justice of victims around the globe. Urban List reader Georgia revealed she "devoured the series in just two days". 

The Dating Game Killer

According Urban List lover Major, this true crime podcast is so eerie you might need to sleep with the ligths on. The story goes like this: In 1987 Rodney Alcala won a date on a reality TV show, The Dating Game. While he charmed everyone, what no one knew was that he was a prolific serial killer in the middle of cross country murder spree. In this six-part series, co-hosts Tracy Pattin and Stephen Lang  take listeners on Alcala’s chilling journey, chronicling his crimes and how he managed to fool everyone around him—from his employers to prison psychiatrists and parole boards. Oh, and did we mention it’s from the creator of Dirty John, so you know it’s going to be epic. 




After more podcasts? Check out our round up of the best newbies dropping on airwaves this month.
Image credit: Johannes Plenio

Get our top stories direct to your inbox.

Get our top stories direct to your inbox.

You May Also Like